Tag Archives: Science

An Anti-Maker Movement?

During my time at the World Science Festival this year I had the opportunity to hear a couple presentations on different topics. I enjoyed most but one presentation in particular rubbed me the wrong way. Normally I would just ease over the rough parts and pluck out the gems but in this case I think the rough parts deserve some attention.

The specific presentation was titled “Mentoring Makers: What’s Wrong with DIY.” In his presentation professor Neil Gershenfeld made a few provocative statements. In essence he feels DIY is, at its core, wrong. The DIY culture leads to the reinvention of past mistakes and doesn’t do enough to mentor young people. As evidence he cites the design of a popular 3D printer which uses wood and screws to compose the body. This design, he says, is faulty. Over time the wood dries out and the screws or bolts loosen. It’s a flaw that has been solved by large firm manufacturers long ago.

His disdain for 3D printers in general was quite evident and extended far beyond the materials used in their construction. His entire presentation was punctuated by the repeated refrain “I hate 3D printers!” He makes a good point that 3D printers aren’t the end-all of home custom fabrication. CNC machines, laser cutters and even basic lathes are all very powerful tools that are more efficient for some designs. A 3D printer, he states, should only be used for designs which are too complex to be made any other way.

While his point is valid on the face of efficiency, a 3D printer allows for a wider array of shapes and objects to be produced at a lower cost and smaller space than an entire workshop of machines. To me the usefulness of the machine is self-evident and shouldn’t be discounted on the basis that it’s not the best tool for all jobs.

Continue reading

Advertisements

World Science Festival 2012 Experience

This year was my first time attending World Science Festival in New York City and I was quite impressed with the variety of events for all ages. I didn’t get to participate in all the events or attend many talks but those I was able to make were diverse and interesting.

My introduction to WSF started with a screening of Icarus at the Edge of Time narrated live by LeVar Burton. I had won 2 tickets the night before and with such short notice, I didn’t have much of a chance to find someone to go. As luck would have it, my boss was a big enough fan of LeVar that he was an easy sell! We both quite enjoyed the experience, held at the amazing United Palace Theater, though it was quite evident the show was meant for a much younger crowd. On the way to the theater from the subway we managed to collide with a family awkwardly looking around for the right way to go. As we all made our way I got lost in a small conversation with mother. The entire family had come for the event because her young son loves physics and science and asked to go! She said there was no way she could turn him down. If I knew how to nominate her for mother of the year, I would have on the spot!

Innovation Square – NYU/Poly at MetroTech, Brooklyn, NY

On Saturday I hopped on the subway and headed to Brooklyn where the NYU/Poly MetroTech campus was playing host to Innovation Square – another family friendly event with booths for people of different ages and interests. Though there were a limited number of exhibits this just made it easier to visit each a few times during the day. I liked to see how people interacted with exhibits and hear the kinds of questions that were asked. At least, that’s the surface explanation. Some exhibits were just so interesting I couldn’t help but revisit them to get a better look as the crowds shifted.

Continue reading